The pattern is also call Star of David and you can find pieces of it pretty easily. I've been looking on e-bay and the large tumblers are hard to find. Here's some that I found......
http://www.ebay.com/itm/4-Early-Amer...item5894e3c999
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-Libb...item3cc9c1257d
Here's some smaller ones.....8 to 10 oz.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/EAPC-Tumbler...item2a21bec570
I'll keep my eyes open too!!
Janet, your purchases look wonderful!! I noticed that one of the cruets match the large bowl you bought when I was there!! Nice!! I really like the bowls on the pedestals and the cracker jar is just beautiful!! You did really good and what fun I'm sure you had! There's nothing more fun than going to an auction, buying some things, then coming home and cleaning them up and displaying them!!
The candle holders will look very nice on your mantle with some colored candles in them. Put one of each holder on each side and put books under one set to make them be at different heights.....use some old books to add some interest!! Fun!!